Amazon Removes Books from Kindle, Exposing the True Concern: They’re Watching, They’re in Control

Amazon has remotely removed copies of George Orwell’s 1984 and Animal Farm from user’s Kindles while crediting their accounts, indicating that the books were improperly added to the Kindle store by a company that did not have the rights to them.

For thousands of users, a book they thought they had properly purchased suddenly disappeared. This, unsurprisingly, caused considerable grief and consternation, arguing that “it‘s like Barnes & Noble sneaking into our homes in the middle of the night, taking some books that we’ve been reading off our nightstands, and leaving us a check on the coffee table.”

As reasonable as this user reaction sounds, a perusal of the Kindle’s terms of service reveals that users aren’t actually buying a book, but merely a license to utilize digital content on their device. While the TOS doesn’t directly state the license is revocable, it does indicate that the license is conditional on Amazon’s authorization, likely giving them the legal authority to remove books from a Kindle whenever they de-authorize its use.

So, yes, while it feels as if Barnes & Noble broke into your house to take back the book you purchased last week, the reality of licensing digital content is different than with brick and mortar. Clearly, we all need to do a better job educating consumers about content licenses, DRMs, and the nature of our digital tools.

But there is a much larger issue here that is being overlooked by many commentators: how simple it is for Amazon to simply take back what they sold you.

More than just an eBook reader, the Kindle is Amazon’s latest cog in its large-scale infrastructure of intellectual surveillance. Moving beyond its (now famous) ability to track one’s book purchases, wish lists, and clickstream activities on, Kindle gives Amazon the power to monitor and collect what you actually do with the books you buy license.

Ted Striphas describes this well in his discussion on “Kindle & the Labor of Reading” (emphasis added):

Much has been made about Kindle’s downstream capabilities—the fact that you can acquire the complete contents of any Kindle-formatted book in under a minute, provided you’re within range of a cell tower. But what about the data it transmits upstream, back to The Kindle license agreement and terms of use are instructive in this regard. In the subsection entitled “Information Received,” the agreement states: “The Device Software will provide Amazon with data about your Device and its interaction with the Service (such as available memory, up-time, log files and signal strength) and information related to content on your Device and your use of it (such as automatic bookmarking of the last page read and content deletions from the Device).” Here’s the especially intriguing part: “Annotations, bookmarks, notes, highlights, or similar markings you make on your Device are backed up through the service and subject to the privacy notice.” And there, it’s worth mentioning, all of the data you generate while reading on your Kindle falls within the purview of “the information we [] collect and analyze” for marketing and related purposes.

This “snoop-friendly” nature of the Kindle is what made it effortless for Amazon to be able to reach in and take back Orwell’s words. The fact that Kindles users went to bed reading Orwell, and woke up the next morning with it suddenly stripped from their Kindles’ memory should be reminder to us all of the power Amazon maintains over readers. The ability to read freely and anonymously continues to be eroded before our (digital) eyes.

UPDATE: Please also read Jack Balkin’s post, where he comes to similar conclusions:

For centuries, we have understood, or rather believed, that owning books came with certain rights, including the right to keep what we purchase and to use it, mark it up, and sell it in any way we like. We were free to purchase books and keep them in our homes, without telling anybody what we were reading, or indeed, what page we had last looked at. Amazon’s Kindle system upends all of these expectations. Amazon knows what books you have on your Kindle, and, in theory, it can even know the book you are currently reading, and even the last page you’ve read on each of the books you own. It can delete books, add books, or modify books, all without your permission. It can change features of the Kindle at will. In upending our assumptions about our freedoms to read books in private and use them as we see fit, Amazon threatens many of the basic freedoms to read we have come to expect in a physical world. If we want to preserve these freedoms, we will have to reform copyright law and privacy law to control the new intermediaries who can control us at a distance.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s